From award shows to C-suites, OTwo Co-Editor Cillian Howley explores if Hollywood is a white place at a white time.
Following the 78th Primetime Emmy Awards last month, the Television Academy faced scrutiny as all winners across the twelve acting categories were white. This occurred in 2021 in a ceremony dubbed #EmmysSoWhite across social media. Of the six additional categories presented at the Creative Arts Emmys, only one winner was an actor of colour. Ernest Harden Jr., who is black, won Outstanding Guest Actor in a Drama Series for The Pitt. Diversity almost always becomes a heated point of conversation during awards season with the 2027 Best Picture race already making headlines.
In May, ahead of The Odyssey’s release, Elon Musk accused director Christopher Nolan of casting Academy Award-winning actress Lupita Nyong’o solely for awards eligibility on X. Ousted from D.C., it seemed Hollywood was the next power town Musk was setting his eyes on. Musk was referencing the new rules for the Best Picture category at the Academy Awards. Announced in 2020 and implemented in 2024, the Representation and Inclusion Standards set quite a low threshold for film productions to compete for the Oscars’ top prize. The 30% diversity figure has been reported but it is not entirely what it seems.
The Academy outlined four standards separated into Onscreen Representation, Creative Leadership, Industry Access and Audience Development. Only sub-targets within two of these have to be met. A production could aim to achieve a cast or crew with 30% from “underrepresented groups” or it could choose a much lower standard and still qualify. For example, a cast or crew with two or more members belonging to “underrepresented groups” is equally acceptable. Had a white actress been cast as Helen of Troy, The Odyssey would be no further from Academy standards.
Racial minorities, women, members of the LGBTQ+, and people with disabilities are also considered “underrepresented groups”. As a black woman, Nyong’o does not count for double in the eyes of awarding bodies as Musk might believe. Of course, the billionaire’s censure was unsuccessful in derailing The Odyssey, with the film-epic grossing over $1.75 billion globally and in the running for this year’s Best Picture statuette.
Despite what Musk and other right-wing culture war perpetrators would have you believe, the bar set by the film body is not high. According to current Academy President Janet Young, all previous Best Picture nominees would remain eligible under the newly introduced standards. As much as this skewers Musk’s argument, it equally begs the question: what good are these standards if they change nothing for artists of colour? Even worse, the Television Academy has no comparable policy, making #EmmysSoWhite all the more likely.
Among Emmy nominees, Abbott Elementary and Paradise stood alone as black-led series up for top prizes in comedy and drama, respectively. Abbott is something of a unicorn as a critical and rating success with a mostly black cast on US network television. The sole acting winner of colour in 2026, Harden Jr., won for The Pitt, a series with a white creator and mostly white stars. A UCLA study found that white people accounted for 79.6% of lead actors and 91.7% of creators of streaming series in 2024. White men alone made up 78.9% of series creators, highlighting a disappointing but predictable marginalisation of racial minorities and women. Even the Shonda Rhimes-produced series Bridgerton, praised for its colour-blind casting and interracial romances, ranks among them with a white creator.
A quick glance at the boardrooms of top streamers explains this problem all too well. CEOs and Heads of Content at Netflix, Disney+ and AppleTV+ are white men. Cindy Ellison, who oversees Paramount+, is unique as a woman at the helm. However, the impact that may have on gender equity at Paramount might be overridden by Paramount-Skydance CEO David Ellison. The son of a billionaire is insistent upon hiring disgraced Hollywood has-beens. Johnny Depp, Brett Ratner and Ellison’s fellow nepo-baby Max Landis are employed thanks to Ellison despite sexual assault allegations.
The billionaire class’s grip on Hollywood makes it hard to foresee the scales of power tipping towards "underrepresented groups”. Like all great monopolies, the Paramount and Warner Bros merger will only consolidate power further in Tinseltown. The recent influx of second and third generation actors is starting to make more sense. Cleared by the US Department of Justice despite antitrust concerns, the impending merger will ensure only Yellowstone spinoffs written by Taylor Sheridan will make it to air.
As is, even successful Black artists are treated with suspicion while their projects face higher barriers to getting the green light and the necessary funding. Black artists in Hollywood are forced to prove themselves to studios who do not believe in their work. With Sinners, writer-director Ryan Coogler was guaranteed final cut approval and first-dollar gross. Still, the film’s blockbuster opening weekend was reported by trade publications with an unhealthy amount of skepticism. Though, Hollywood has a reputation to some as some liberal safe haven; this has already been shown to be untrue. With Trump-supporting billionaires taking the reins, conditions seem to only be worsening for minority creatives.
.png)